Scammer or Liar?

As you all may be aware, there was a recent post on Perez by elite-girl(Linda), stating that SeasonalHotbuys was hacked by Tylerisbold. 

That statement came through during Radio Perez when SeasonalHotbuys showed us "proof" of this. I immediately believed her because of my feelings towards Tyler. And also because I was told by him that they accounts were donated. He also asked me to help sell the items from SeasonalHotbuy's closet to his account for prizes.

These are the Skype messages I received from Tyler, months ago.

Asking me to help move the items.

Today I received Skype messages from Tyler after not talking for months. He said to me that he read what I said in a comment on PSG about him and he wanted me to know that he did not hack those accounts.

As you read, he goes onto say that those accounts were donated. And he provides his form of "proof"

These images below were sent to me by  Tyler. 

They are from SeasonalHotbuys, who was at the time on her other account.

Pop_star1234.

They do give out her passwords, Which Tyler says are now changed, so don't bother trying to log into her accounts, curious ones.

My only issue with this is the fact that he cannot provide messages that say she was donating the accounts.

So who do you believe?

The elite who has a scarred reputation?

And isn't well known for his people skills.

Or the seemingly nice girl that could be deceiving us?

What do you think?